Progressive rock’s emergence represented the moment that rock n’ roll grew up and decided it wasn’t going to merely rely on making people dance any longer. This wasn’t cool music anymore, but it sure was clever. It was book-smart and technically capable.
It wasn’t jazz, either. This was music that took you on a journey, having more in common with folk tales and fantasy games than with motorcycle gangs or music teachers dressed in turtleneck shirts.
Everything about progressive music was oversized. And against all the naysayers and prophecies, it lives, thrives, and records made during its golden era still sell in the bucketloads.
There are many important progressive bands which have been started recently. But today, we are focusing on the very best, old and new. I am talking about the bands who wrote great concept albums, who tried to turn rock into a respectable art form, and, more often than not, wore their LARPing gear on stage. I am counting down the greatest prog-rock bands of all-time.
The 100 Best Prog-Rock Bands of All-Time
1. Pink Floyd
Pink Floyd was “trippy” before it was “progressive.” At least, that’s what highly-devoted fans thought of the band’s evolution. Starting out as a vehicle for architecture students to spread rock n’ roll to the outer reaches of its psychedelic potential and led by the eccentricities of Syd Barrett, Pink Floyd was the hit of underground London.
Barrett, by most accounts, sadly, went mad. It meant that The Floyd had to retreat, for a while, into free-form experimentation and reduce the number of pop moments in the vein of “See Emily Play.”
It wasn’t the dead end that everyone predicted. Because of the early 1970s, the music world was ready for a bit more complexity. This had been just for which Roger Waters had been pining. Waters’ philosophical laments of “Dark Side of the Moon” and “Shine on You Crazy Diamond” made the band, less so the band members, into a superstar group.
By the time of “The Wall,” every nuance of their music was poured over by serious critics, not like an idiot writing these words. And, even though, sans Waters, things took a turn for the poppier under David Gilmour’s rule, Pink Floyd remained the great prog-rock band by which most others are judged. To think it all started with a bunch of strobe lights in a London cellar.
2. Yes
Yes was the band that Jon Anderson always thought that The Beatles secretly wanted to become. Of all the Spinal Tap-like cliches attributed to prog-rock bands, in general, in fact, most of them belong to Yes.
But the ambition was based on incredible musical ability from the very beginning. After a series of false starts, Yes found its audience with a series of musically adventurous albums in the 70s. How adventurous? Apparently, the bill to buy Rick Wakeman his keyboards nearly bankrupted the group.
Songs and albums kept getting longer, and for a while, the audiences kept getting larger. The cult-like obedience of fans was less dependable by the end of the 80s.
But, as was the fate of many a great prog-rock group, by the 80s, with several lineup changes under its belt, Yes emerged as a pop sensation. Reunions, feuds, and a return to making “classic prog-rock” were all relatively successful. It leaves Yes as a hard act to follow for anyone wanting to make double albums about fantasy lands using plenty of keyboards and complex guitar solos.
3. Genesis
The musicians of Genesis were always fated to make prog-rock. They were classmates from a fancy boarding school, they were highly intelligent, they dressed funny, and they were English.
Managing somehow to put all of those elements together and led by the ever-ambitious theatrics of Peter Gabriel, Genesis became an important live draw in the early 1970s. Concept albums and their stage presentation became something of a gold standard for the genre. The musicianship and storytelling of albums like “The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway” are serious and successful artistic statements.
Gabriel’s departure was an excuse to disguise the prog-rock elements. It was just in time. This was the 80s, and nobody got more picked on than “progressive” musicians. With Phil Collins singing, Genesis enjoyed great pop success. Yet, if you listen closely and can count uneven time signatures, you’ll still find traces of ye ole prog-rock.
4. Rush
The best prog-rock bands keep fans invested and investing over many decades. This is what Rush did for its fans, musical fanatics who, more often than not, own every single album in the band’s lengthy discography.
Rush could’ve been the Canadian Led Zeppelin if Geddy Lee and Alex Lifeson had their way. But by the time Ayn Rand-loving drummer and songwriter Neil Peart joined the band, the desire was to find unparalleled excellence.
The trio did just that. Largely ignored by the critics and often savaged for their fashion sense, Rush made one classic after another during the 1970s. In an era dominated by prog-rock bands, few were more consistent and hard-working than this trio.
By the early 80s, Rush parlayed this success into radio hits and even toyed with synths and pop elements on a number of albums. They called it quits for nearly a decade before returning to monumental fan support in the 2000s. The sad passing of Neil Peart put an end to the group. But what was left behind was the kind of enormous musically progressive statement at which Rand herself would’ve blushed.
5. Dream Theater
Dream Theater was an elite kill squad of prog-rock musicians on a suicide mission. What made the chances of survival as a group so slim? By the late 80s, when Dream Theater was formed by Berklee College students, progressive rock was no longer very successful. Not even rock fans wanted to hear it, and 80s rock fans wouldn’t have tolerated anything.
However, progressive metal bands, a separate but connected strand, had shown there was potential for an audience. This was, of course, provided you could play heavy, fast, and tell a story. Queensryche and Fate’s Warning had done this very well.
Incredibly musically proficient and able to spin a yarn through song, Dream Theater became a surprise hit with the album “Images and Words.” By the 2000s, the band was practically a genre onto itself. They’ve maintained a highly loyal following until this day. And, yes, no drum, keyboard, or guitar solo has ever been long enough for Boston band.
6. Jethro Tull
Jethro Tull didn’t start out as a progressive rock band. But then again, few of the classics did. Nah, Ian Anderson wanted a blues-rock band just like the others who were making a bit of dough in England in the late 1960s.
An interest in classical music, the fact that the musicians looked kinda funny on stage, and a nice sense of humor pushed Jethro Tull in the arms of progressive music.
Serious musicians, as they now were, Tull’s members created the muscular “Aqualung,” or the faux-concept album “Thick as a Brick.” By the late 1970s, millions had bought the band’s albums, and most confessed to not knowing what this Jethro Tull character making all this racket looked like.
The truly classic releases somewhat dried up by the end of the 1970s. But Anderson guided forward, prog-rock flag in hand. Jethro Tull continues to play to a cult following all over the world.
7. Queen
Most progressive rock bands became pop-rock bands in the 1980s once the bill started piling up. Queen’s quartet, on the other hand, saw the writing on the wall early.
Sure, most people associate Queen with similar pop hits played on the stage of Wembley Stadium. However, during the 1970s, few groups were as clever or wrote compositions that were as rich and complex as Queen. To not be included on the list of the greatest progressive rock bands would be a crime on par with letting Paul Rodgers sing “Bohemian Rhapsody.”
If anything, the sophomore release, “Queen II,” was the band’s shining musical moment. Heavy-sounding, ambitious and inspired by ancient myths and dubious fashion choices, “Queen II” hints at a future where Dungeons and Dragons players and heavy metal fans can live as one.
Commercially, Queen’s progressive era reached its zenith with “A Night at the Opera,” an album inspired by dead or dying musical forms. By the 1980s, there were fewer 10-minute songs in live playlists. But the progressive gospel was recorded for all to hear. Freddie Mercury was prog fan from London before was a rock god.
8. King Crimson
King Crimson is the essential prog-rock unit, monks of musical complexity and, believed to never smile. But if anything, King Crimson created a market. Their debut album, “In the Court of the Crimson King,” was a monster hit. It created a demand for complex musicianship and intricate storytelling. And essentially, it broke up the initial version of the group.
Led by guitarist Robert Fripp, King Crimson continued to challenge rock fans during the 1970s. The ever more intricate and abstract material nearly always demanded that the musician sit down while playing. Fans bothered little ith this detail.
By the 2000s when they were ready to call it a day, King Crimson had the following of a religious cult, some of its band members had formed other successful groups (like Emerson, Lake and Palmer or Asia), and the early 1970s records were held in the highest esteem.
There’s a ladder that prog-rock fans have to climb. King Crimson is most surely up at the very top, in between “really demanding” and “I give up.”
9. TOOL
An essential part of being part of a successful prog-rock band is a mistrust of your over-enthusiastic fanbase. TOOL’s singer, Maynard James Keenan, has often complained about this. But how could it have been any different?
TOOL’s second and third albums, “Aenima” and “Lateralus,” made progressive rock fanatics of alt-rock and grunge kids. TOOL’ s music was mysterious, well-played, heavy and highly intricate.
The fanaticism kept TOOL in business. And, even though the group’s only been able to reconvene to make another two albums since then, its influence is colossal. Walk into any practice space and you’ll hear kids trying to master the otherworldly mood of TOOL’s music and the complex sound signatures.
10. Opeth
Scandinavians and people recovering from broken limbs spend the most amount of time indoors. The former often use this time to create unwelcoming art that displays their virtuosity.
By the early 90s, the Northerners were fighting each other in wars of heavy metal. Opeth was among the competitors in the category of “World’s Most Evil Bands.” But growling and blast beats alone can only get you so far.
Mikael Åkerfeldt’s leadership took the band to a more complex territory, peaking in the early 2000s with albums like “Blackwater Park.” From then onward, Opeth was placed at the vanguard of a new kind of progressive rock. This version reveled in darkness and operated as comfortably with death metal elements as they did with classic rock ones.
Typical of Swedes, Opeth’s musicians remained hard-rock working and consistent. They released many other well-acclaimed albums, built a global fanbase and created their own brand of prog-rock. All of this means that to not include them would be to ignore all the work done by all of those young men and women stuck in their Swedish garages for 6-8 months of the year.
11. Emerson, Lake and Palmer
12. Peter Gabriel
13. Can
14. The Mars Volta
15. Gentle Giant
16. Van der Graaf Generator
17. Porcupine Tree
18. Supertramp
19. Queensryche
20. Marillion
21. Magma
22. Procol Harum
23. King’s X
24. Soft Machine
25. Hawkwind
26. Gong
27. Transatlantic
28. Wishbone Ash
29. Styx
30. Be Bob Deluxe
31. Return to Forever
32. Aprodite’s Child
33. UK
34. Spock’s Beard
35. Focus
36. Utopia
37. Camel
38. Mastodon
39. Steven Wilson (solo)
40. Manfred Mann’s Earth Band
41. Uriah Heep
42. Mike Oldfield
43. Caravan
44. Therion
45. The Flower Kings
46. Electric Light Orchestra
47. Asia
48. The Pineapple Thief
49. Gojira
50. Devin Townsend
51. Fate’s Warning
52. Between the Buried and Me
53. Messhugah
54. Karnivool
55. The Pretty Things
56. Baroness
57. Premiata Forneria Marconi
58. Tangerine Dream
59. Enslaved
60. The Alan Parsons Project
61. Nektar
62. Kansas
63. The Moody Blues
64. Animlas as Leaders
65. Crack the Sky
66. Symphony X
67. Coheed and Cambria
68. Haken
69. Periphery
70. Sky
71. Dragon
72. Omega
73. Renaisance
74. Leprous
75. Riverside
76. Katatonia
77. TesseracT
78. VOLA
79. Pavlov’s Dog
80. Caligula’s Horse
81. Obscura
82. The Contortionist
83. Curved Air
84. Ayreon
85. The Strawbs
86. Liquid Tension Experiment
87. The Ocean
88. Barclay James Harvest
89. Arena
90. Fish
91. Family
92. Klaatu
93. IQ
94. Textures
95. Anderson Bruford Wakeman Howe
96. Delivery
97. Wheel
98. Seventh Wonder
99. Greenslade
100. Audience
Ridiculous! How are Caravan, Van de Graaf, Camel so low.
Got it right with Yes, Genesis, Floyd. Rush is a #1 candidate for me